Siesta Key TRENDS | 2023 Year End + 2024 Forecast

2024 SIESTA KEY FORECAST: A Reflection of Resilience & Luxury

As we begin 2024, the Siesta Key real estate market stands as a testament to enduring resilience. 2023 has been a narrative of subtle shifts and steadfast values, epitomizing the enduring desire for the island lifestyle and stability that Siesta Key is renowned for.

The overarching sentiment as we bid adieu to 2023 is one of cautious yet palpable optimism. The market dynamics this year have been reflective of a thoughtful and deliberate decision-making process, indicative of a market that values quality and foresight. The calming of mortgage rates and the consistent influx of discerning buyers, retirees, and investors to Sarasota continues to underpin the market’s vitality.

In a market that speaks the language of luxury and discernment, the single-family homes sector paints a picture of steady assurance. Witnessing a slight recalibration, the average sales price for single-family homes adjusted to $2,403,011, a nuanced variation from the previous year. This gentle modulation is not a detour but a sign of a self-correcting market that mirrors the cautious optimism of national trends. Amidst this, Siesta Key has maintained its allure, with premier properties—those boasting of state-of-the-art construction or those transformed through meticulous renovations—continuing to captivate high-end buyers.

The condominium market, a vibrant tapestry of modernity and convenience, has seen a remarkable upswing. Climbing to an average sales price of $1,060,312, it marks a significant 14.9% increase year-over-year. This surge is a clear indicator of the undiminished appeal of Siesta Key’s condos, which combine the essence of luxury living with the serene beauty of Sarasota’s Gulf Coast. The demand for these strategically located sanctuaries remains robust, reflecting the aspirations of those seeking a harmonious blend of luxury and ease.

Looking forward, the Siesta Key market is poised on the cusp of steady, measured progress. The demand for high-caliber homes in this sought-after enclave remains unwavering. In 2024, the market is expected to sustain its tempered yet positive momentum, reaffirming Siesta Key’s status as a premier destination for refined living.



“There is a reason Judie Berger is so successful - she focuses on the details and she does the work! Her superpower is her intelligence, and she uses that gift so well in determining the essential value of your property and how to bring it most effectively to the market. She is strategic, and very data driven in her analysis. With that analytical orientation, she is able to read the sometimes very subtle signals of the market, often before others. She is a very seasoned professional with deep knowledge and experience. And on top of all that, she is a pleasure to work with. We easily give her our highest recommendation.” 

- Marge Dolan & Veronica Murry



“You can’t go wrong with Judie Berger! When I decided to sell my home on Siesta Key, I wanted to find the best, most experienced realtor to help me market and sell my property. I had interviewed three or four realtors when I met Judie Berger. It was evident after the first five minutes of our conversation that she was far superior in knowledge, personality and experience to any of the other realtors I had interviewed. She was extremely knowledgeable about the Sarasota real estate market and she came prepared with a marketing plan to sell my home. Without hesitation, I chose Judie to list my house and I’m sure glad I did.” 

- Allen Carman



“We could not be happier with our experience with Judie Berger and her team. Judie helped us with the sale of our home on Siesta Key and the purchase of our new home on Siesta Key. She is friendly and a pleasure to deal with, very detail-oriented and listened to what was important to us. Also, her experience and knowledge meant that we had no surprises at closing for either transaction. We were in really good hands all along the process for both the sale and the purchase of our properties and we would not want to use anyone else should we be in the market again.”

- Harald & Cori Hvideberg



Have we met yet? If you’re considering a move and would like to discuss detailed information about market trends in your neighborhood with Siesta Key’s top-selling agent, please contact me for a confidential consultation; I look forward to discussing your real estate goals with you. For a full report on Siesta Key and the Sarasota-Manatee area that is sent regularly to my private client list, please contact me at 941.928.3424  or [email protected].

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Post a Comment