Bay Island Real Estate

Included below are homes for sale on Bay Island. If you would like more information on any of these Bay Island real estate listings, just click the "Request More Information" button when viewing the details of that property. We can provide you with disclosures, past sales history, dates and prices of homes recently sold nearby, and more.

And, if you haven't already, be sure to register for a free account so that you can receive email alerts whenever new Bay Island listings come on the market.

Available Bay Island Listings September 25, 2022
7
Listed
63
Avg. DOM
$1,108.50
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$4,350,000
Med. List Price
7 Properties
$12,600,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Rep 01
5
Beds
4F21/2
Baths
7,487
Sq.Ft.
137
Days on Site
A4534680
MLS
Under Construction. Experience the majestic, private waterfront setting of this dazzling residence on Siesta Key with an approximate completion date of December 2022. Boasting 128' of water frontage...
$6,500,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island/Siesta Key
5
Beds
5F21/2
Baths
4,985
Sq.Ft.
2023
Year Built
25
Days on Site
A4546740
MLS
Pre-Construction. To be built. A dream home built by well-respected Voigt Brothers Construction on 95 ft of water frontage. Great boating waters on Hanson Bayou with easy access and no bridges to the...
$6,000,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Shores Unit 1
4
Beds
4F21/2
Baths
6,395
Sq.Ft.
2006
Year Built
72
Days on Site
A4542278
MLS
This stunning north Siesta Key estate on sailboat water offers deep-water dockage and multiple lifts for serious boaters. Experience the magnificence of this impressive, private harbor-front...
$4,350,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Shores
6
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
4,434
Sq.Ft.
1956
Year Built
83
Days on Site
A4539684
MLS
Step into this beautiful world, where you can enjoy the luxuries that only come with waterfront living. It offers 90' of waterfront with quick access to the Gulf of Mexico. Entering the private gate...
$3,900,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
4
Beds
3F21/2
Baths
3,960
Sq.Ft.
2004
Year Built
59
Days on Site
A4543853
MLS
Revel in the spectacular Siesta Key lifestyle in one of Sarasota's finest neighborhoods with luxury homes that redefine island living. With serenity and privacy, along with easy big water access,...
Open 9/25
3532 Flamingo Ave Sarasota, FL 34242
$3,749,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
3
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
3,162
Sq.Ft.
1950
Year Built
57
Days on Site
A4543285
MLS
A boater's dream offering 70ft of shoreline on the Hanson Bayou. A unique combination of sophistication and luxury awaits you in the quaint neighborhood of Bay Island. Enjoy watching dolphins play in...
$1,850,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
5
Beds
4
Baths
2,709
Sq.Ft.
1939
Year Built
18
Days on Site
A4537131
MLS
SIESTA KEY LIVING!!! Welcome home to your island getaway situated in the number one beach in the nation! A short five minute walk will have you dipping your toes in private shell beach or a five...